Pitfalls of a single-tool approach in user recruitment
Finding the right people to take part in research is a complex process that requires a thorough approach in order to be successful – we have learnt this much after 25 years working in the user research and UX industry. It also requires a company and its team to be flexible and able to diversify its approach and constantly develop new ways to find participants.
A single-tool approach can be more damaging than beneficial when trying to find your users – which is why you (or your participant recruitment partner) should never exclusively rely on one source of participants for your sessions. For example, when designing research, you wouldn’t use only one methodology, right?
At People for Research, we use social media regularly to recruit people that are interested in sharing their feedback about products and services, but we also grow and develop our own online community using sources other than social media and continuously find new groups of people to share their opinion with our clients. From our experience, it’s virtually impossible to rely on one single source of participants, but some companies do it – keep reading to find out more about the pitfalls of this approach.
Usually, when a company, design agency or user recruitment expert use social media to find participants for their sessions, they tend to follow the route of paid advertisement. This means that the person or team posting the ad or series of ads on Facebook, for example, will look at their recruitment criteria and try to show a paid post or image carousel, for example, to the people who match said criteria, in the hope that they will be interested and eager to take part in research or testing. So, what are the dangers of this approach?
Potential lack of engagement
Maybe you have a good following on Facebook, with several thousands of people liking your page. However, posting a paid ad and showing it to a targeted audience is a completely different ballgame.
The majority of the people who will see your paid post are unlikely to know anything about your company, as you haven’t built a relationship with them. Although most people will find the offer of a cash incentive appealing, it may not be enough to make them stay with you throughout a strict screening process and this can potentially lead to people dropping out on the day of the session.
Our online lives don’t necessarily match reality
Social media has taught us at least two important lessons: people live online lives that are sometimes different from their real lives and social media affects the way we live (and even our decisions).
People curate, sometimes unconsciously, their social media feeds to make their lives look more exciting. A study conducted by Hancock, Toma, & Ellison analysed 80 online daters and found that 2/3 of participants lied about their weight by five pounds or more. In 2016, a larger study including over 2,000 people in England found out that over three quarters of participants lie on social media: only 18% of men and 19% of women that took part in this survey reported that their Facebook page displayed “a completely accurate reflection” of who they are.
And then there’s also the fact that social media directly affects the way we live our lives. Dr Amit Mitra, from the University of the West of England (UWE), recently published a study on the influence of social media use on the situational ethnicity of migrants. His conclusion:
“In contrast. social media-based engagement by migrants highlights encouragement of effects of isolation, and consequent ghetto-isation. Drawing upon extant literature on anthropology of migration, we argue that migrants’ use of social media creates a liminality that is synonymous to ambiguity and disorientation that may diminish through a composite adaptation of virtual and physical ethnic identities.”
Targeting on social media is still limited
Sure, you can target pretty much any demographic information on Facebook and show ads to the people you believe are suitable to take part in your research. However, as the previous point explained, people don’t always tell the truth on social media, so you need to at least allow for a margin of error when setting up paid ads and make sure these people go through a very thorough screening process before they become participants in your research.
Secondly, if you have tried targeting a specific audience on social media, you would have noticed the following:
Some targeting categories have been optimised for specific countries and their context.
Targeting demographics might be easy, but accurately targeting most behaviours is inaccurate or not possible.
Not everyone will be on social media
If you are planning to rely exclusively on social media to recruit your participants – this is particularly relevant/true if you are planning to use only one social media channel –, you are likely to end up with a similar group of people with similar tech-savviness levels.
Users younger than 25 years old are not particularly interested in or active on Facebook in 2018 and people with low tech confidence are not likely to be using it. The same goes for people with impairments who may feel that Facebook is not assistive technology-friendly. This is just an example of a few groups of people you will be missing out if you focus on one social media channel or on social media exclusively.
If you are interested in finding out more about our comprehensive approach to user recruitment, drop us an email on email@example.com or browse our blog.
📢 New blog alert 📢 Finding the right people to take part in #UserResearch is a complex process! On our new blog, we share four reasons why a single-tool approach in #UserRecruitment can be more damaging than beneficial to your research or testing | https://t.co/zEVfy0FLRZ pic.twitter.com/gbqXeu8qeJ
— People for Research (@people4research) November 26, 2018
9 top questions we get asked by clients
If you would like to find out more about our in-house participant recruitment service for user testing or market research get in touch on 0117 921 0008 or firstname.lastname@example.org.
About the author: Maria Santos is the Digital Marketing Manager at People for Research. You can find her on the People for Research’s Facebook or Twitter accounts, regularly engaging with potential participants, market research experts and the UX community.
About People for Research: We recruit participants for UX and usability testing and market research. We work with award winning UX agencies across the UK and partner with a number of end clients who are leading the way with in-house user experience and insight.
Contact us for…
Pick our brains, we love chatting about people and how to find them.
Each brief is unique, for a cost for your particular brief, please contact us.
Viewing facility / usability lab
People for Research have a flexible lab space, with the ability to host usability testing, focus groups and in depth interviews.
- 0117 921 0008
People for Research
Queen Charlotte Street
91 Wimpole Street